Subscribe
Economy

Funding tops concerns as ​State Police Bill awaits Tinubu’s nod

9 minutes read
50 Views

As President Bola Tinubu prepares to sign the constitutional amendment establishing State Police, Nigeria’s 36 states face a key question: can they afford to run effective police services without deepening the country’s existing security and fiscal inequalities?

Advertisement

The Senate had on Wednesday directed the National Assembly to transmit the bill to the President without delay.

The expected assent on is a major step towards decentralising Nigeria’s policing system, which has remained largely under the control of the Federal Government since independence.

But while the amendment will provide the constitutional foundation for the State Police, the financial and institutional demands of setting up and sustaining the new services could prove more difficult than securing political agreement for the reform.

For states already struggling to meet salary obligations, fund infrastructure and deliver basic services, the responsibility of recruiting, training, equipping and maintaining a police force could impose a substantial additional burden.

The concerns go beyond the initial cost of recruitment and equipment. They include the payment of salaries and allowances, pensions, insurance, vehicles, communication systems, operational logistics, police stations, forensic facilities and continuous training.

They also raise questions about whether poorer states will be able to provide the same quality of policing as wealthier states, and whether the reform could create a security system in which the protection available to citizens depends partly on the financial capacity of the state in which they live.

Lawrence Alobi, a retired Commissioner of Police and Sadeeq Shehu, a former military intelligence officer and international security consultant have warned that the success of the reform will depend heavily on how these funding and institutional challenges are addressed.

While Alobi advocates a national funding arrangement that would draw contributions from the Federal Government, states and the private sector, Shehu proposes a State Police Equalisation Fund to prevent financially weaker states from being left behind.

Their recommendations point to a central challenge for the Tinubu administration: decentralising policing without fragmenting the country’s capacity to provide security.

The financial implications of the reform are considerable because states will not simply be creating new government departments. They will be establishing security institutions with substantial recurrent and capital expenditure requirements.

Read also: Tinubu appoints Agboola Dibiri Commissioner at NASC

An earlier implementation framework for State Police proposed a 60-month transition period, with 60 per cent of existing police personnel transferred to state services and 40 per cent retained by the Federal Government. It also proposed a national police strength of 566,306 officers.

The framework reportedly contemplated a funding arrangement involving a three per cent contribution from the Federation Account into a proposed State Police Fund, alongside a minimum 15 per cent contribution from each state’s security budget.

These were proposals in an earlier framework, not confirmed provisions of the final National Policing Bill. Nevertheless, they illustrate the scale of the funding debate and the difficulty of determining how the financial responsibility should be shared.

Governors have also expressed concern that a three per cent contribution from the Federation Account may be insufficient to meet the recurrent expenditure of the proposed services, particularly salaries and allowances.

The question is especially important because the cost of policing does not end once officers are recruited and equipment procured. A state must be able to sustain its police service year after year, including when revenue falls or competing demands on its budget increase.

The financial position of the existing Nigeria Police Force offers a warning about what could happen if the new services are established without a reliable funding structure.

The Ministry of Police Affairs’ 2026 budget is about N1.33 trillion, comprising approximately N1.268 trillion in recurrent expenditure and N60.9 billion in capital expenditure.

Separately, the Nigeria Police Trust Fund has an allocation of about N233.96 billion for the year, including N222.89 billion for capital expenditure and N11.07 billion for recurrent spending.

The proposed state services will add another layer of expenditure, with each state expected to provide the infrastructure, personnel and operational capacity necessary to police its territory.

The existing Police Act 2020 already provides for a Police General Fund, with sources of funding including Federal Government budgetary allocations, contributions from state governments and the Federal Capital Territory, international assistance, grants and other sources.

The law permits the fund to be used for salaries, allowances, pensions, operational costs, buildings, training and research. This provides an existing statutory basis for contributions beyond the Federal Government, although the funding arrangements required for a decentralised policing system will need to be clearly defined.

The financial debate is also taking place against the backdrop of longstanding concerns about the welfare and operational conditions of serving police officers.

On November 12, the Ministry of Police Affairs disclosed that a committee reviewing police remuneration and welfare had identified inadequate allowances, poor implementation of existing entitlements and gaps in personnel welfare.

The review reportedly identified concerns around pension arrears, death benefits, insurance and operational overheads. It also found that there were no active insurance policies covering personnel and key assets for 2025 and 2026, while provisions for vehicle and motorcycle fuel and maintenance were inadequate.

Earlier, on November 4, Ibrahim Gaidam, the Minister of Police Affairs, said the ministry was seeking to increase the police insurance provision from N30 billion to about N102 billion, subject to confirmation.

The government has also announced plans to recruit 50,000 additional police officers, adding to the personnel and welfare responsibilities that must be financed.

These developments raise a difficult question: if the Federal Government is still grappling with the cost of adequately maintaining the existing police force, how will states with considerably smaller revenue bases meet the demands of running their own services?

The salary structure also illustrates the recurrent nature of the commitment. Under the CONPOSS salary adjustment approved in 2024, the reproduced first-step annual salary for a Constable II was about N622,452, equivalent to approximately N51,871 monthly.
The corresponding figures for a Constable I and a Corporal were about N633,962 and N654,795 annually, respectively.

These figures are indicative salary-table figures and should not be treated as a complete picture of current take-home pay, which may vary with allowances and applicable adjustments. But even before adding pensions, insurance, training, accommodation and operational costs, the cumulative wage bill of a state police service could be substantial.

Alobi believes that leaving the financing of State Police entirely to individual state governments could undermine the reform before it becomes fully operational.

He proposed a National Police Trust Fund, supported by contributions from the Federal Government, state governments and companies operating in the states.

“I said the police should have a trust fund that is being grown and funded by the federal government,” he said.

“The state government should be made to pay a part of that trust fund, and all companies in the state should contribute a proportion of their profits to that trust fund.”

He said the proposed fund should be managed by an independent body rather than politicians, to prevent political interference and ensure that resources are directed towards policing needs.

“I think they should establish a trust fund that will be supervised by an independent body, not politicians,” he said.

Alobi explained that the fund should not be restricted to supporting state police services but should also strengthen the Federal Police, given the need for cooperation in tackling crimes that cross state boundaries.

He cited the example of criminal activities that may originate in one state and extend into another, arguing that state police services would still require federal intervention and coordination.

Read also: FG domestic borrowing hits 110% of annual target in September

“That intervention by the Federal Government should also be an element of control and coordination,” he said.

Alobi said a trust fund to support states that might struggle to finance their police services, arguing that the financial capacity of states should not determine whether they can establish effective policing institutions.

Shehu, also warned that differences in the revenue-generating capacity of states could produce unequal policing standards across the country.

In his analysis of the State Police debate, he argued that allowing each state to finance its police service without a national equalisation mechanism could leave poorer states unable to recruit, train and equip officers to the required standard.

‘If state like Lagos Rivers and the states that have the money are able to finance their police what happ3ns to states with no money. What happens to the police there?

” We can’t give arms to people and not pay them well. Considering the current payment structure of the police in itself, I’m not sure many states can pay well.”

“Poorer states should not be condemned to inferior policing,” he said.

Shehu proposed the establishment of a State Police Equalisation Fund, financed from the Federation Account, to support states that cannot independently meet the minimum financial requirements for effective policing.

Under his proposal, “allocations should not be distributed equally across the 36 states but determined by a formula that considers population, land area, crime burden, poverty levels, internally generated revenue and compliance with national policing standards.’

He also recommended minimum national funding standards for salaries, training, equipment, communication systems and personnel welfare.

States unable to meet these standards would receive conditional Federal Government support, while grants to states should be linked to their compliance with requirements on training, human rights, accountability and financial audits.

The proposal is intended to address the risk that wealthier states such as Lagos and Rivers could develop better-equipped and more professional police services, while states with weaker revenue bases struggle to provide even basic operational resources.

Shehu also argued that the Federal Government should continue to fund national policing functions that would be unnecessarily expensive for individual states to duplicate.

These include national forensic laboratories, DNA databases, fingerprint and biometric systems, criminal intelligence databases, police aviation, cybercrime capabilities and major training academies.

In his view, states should bear the cost of routine policing within their jurisdictions, while the Federal Government provides national infrastructure and support for states that cannot meet the required standards.

His recommendations also address the possibility that a state police service could become dysfunctional because of financial or administrative difficulties. He argued that the legal framework should provide for Federal Police intervention in such circumstances.