Subscribe
Entrepreneurship

State Police: What Tinubu’s National Policing Bill must get right

10 minutes read
0 Views

Nigeria’s move towards decentralised policing is approaching a critical stage, with the National Assembly expected to consider the legislation that will determine how the proposed state police system operates, including its funding, command structure, accountability mechanisms and relationship with the Federal Police Service.

Advertisement

The development follows the approval of the constitutional amendment establishing State Police Services by all 36 State Houses of Assembly, clearing the way for President Bola Tinubu to assent to the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (Sixth Alteration) Bill, 2026.

The Senate had passed the amendment on June 24, while the House of Representatives approved it on July 23. After receiving the required endorsement from the state legislatures, the National Assembly directed its Clerk, Kamoru Ogunlana, to transmit the amendment to the President for assent.

However, the Senate, at its plenary on November 18, also urged Tinubu to transmit the proposed National Policing Bill to the National Assembly for legislative scrutiny and expeditious passage.

Read also: Funding tops concerns as ​State Police Bill awaits Tinubu’s nod

The distinction between the two pieces of legislation is significant. While the constitutional amendment creates the legal foundation for a dual policing structure, the National Policing Bill will establish the operational framework for the Federal Police Service and State Police Services.

The Presidential Working Group on the National Policing Bill, chaired by Femi Gbajabiamila, Chief of Staff to the President, completed the drafting stage of the proposed legislation and submitted it, alongside 29 consequential amendment bills, to the Federal Ministry of Justice on October 19 for legislative drafting review and validation.

The proposed framework covers national policing standards, state readiness certification, federal and state policing responsibilities, personnel management, police oversight, human rights, firearms control, funding, intelligence systems and the transition from the existing centralised arrangement.

But as the proposal approaches legislative consideration, questions about the safeguards necessary to prevent political interference, ensure accountability and guarantee equal access to security services across states are becoming increasingly important.

For the National Assembly, the challenge will be to ensure that the legislation does not merely create additional police institutions but establishes a system capable of protecting citizens regardless of their political affiliation, location or the financial capacity of their state.

One of the most sensitive issues lawmakers must address is the extent of control governors will exercise over state police services.

Under the proposed arrangement, governors will have a significant role in the establishment and administration of state police institutions. While proponents argue that this will bring policing closer to communities and improve responsiveness to local security threats, concerns remain about the possibility of governors using the institutions to settle political scores, intimidate opponents or suppress dissent.

Nigeria’s political history provides reasons for such concerns, particularly where public institutions have been accused of being deployed against opposition figures and critics of government.

The National Policing Bill must therefore clearly distinguish between the governor’s constitutional responsibility for public safety and the operational independence required by a professional police institution.

It should specify the circumstances under which governors can issue directives to state police commissioners, the nature of such directives and the procedures for documenting them.

Read also: Enugu Assembly backs state police, warns against intimidation

Any instruction capable of influencing arrests, investigations, deployments or the use of force should be subject to clearly defined legal limits.

The legislation should also establish safeguards against arbitrary appointment and removal of police commissioners, while ensuring that state assemblies and independent oversight institutions have meaningful powers to scrutinise police administration.

Beyond political office holders, citizens must have accessible mechanisms to challenge unlawful arrests, intimidation, excessive use of force and other abuses by state police personnel.

Without these safeguards, decentralisation could transfer the concentration of policing power from the Federal Government to individual state governments without adequately strengthening citizens’ protection.

Another issue requiring detailed legislative attention is the division of responsibilities between the Federal Police Service and State Police Services.

With both institutions expected to operate within the same geographical space, the National Policing Bill must establish clear jurisdictional boundaries and procedures for cooperation.

Questions surrounding investigations, arrests, intelligence gathering and the handling of crimes involving multiple states could create institutional friction if responsibilities are not clearly defined.

For instance, a kidnapping investigation that begins in one state but extends into neighbouring states may require the involvement of several police commands. Similarly, organised crime, terrorism, cybercrime and financial crimes may involve federal and state jurisdictions simultaneously.

The legislation must clarify which institution takes the lead in such investigations, how cases are transferred, who coordinates joint operations and how disagreements between the services are resolved.

It must also establish effective intelligence-sharing arrangements, including access to national criminal databases, forensic facilities, biometric information and other investigative resources.

The objective should be to prevent a situation where the introduction of state police creates competing authorities or allows criminals to exploit jurisdictional gaps.

Read also: State police take-off hinges on operational framework as Tinubu receives constitutional amendment bill

Nationally coordinated capabilities, particularly those requiring sophisticated technology and substantial investment, should also be available to state police services under clearly regulated arrangements.

The National Assembly must also pay particular attention to accountability mechanisms, especially the investigation of complaints against police officers.

Nigeria’s experience with police brutality, unlawful detention, torture and extrajudicial killings makes this one of the most important aspects of the proposed reform.

Although establishing police services closer to communities could improve public engagement, proximity alone does not guarantee accountability.

The National Policing Bill should provide for independent police complaints institutions with clearly defined investigative powers, operational independence and adequate funding.

Cases involving deaths in custody, torture, sexual violence, unlawful firearms discharge and other serious violations should trigger mandatory independent investigations rather than being left entirely to the internal disciplinary structures of the police service involved.

The legislation should also provide for transparent reporting of complaints, investigation outcomes, disciplinary measures and compliance with human rights standards.

The role of state assemblies in exercising oversight must be clearly defined, alongside the responsibilities of the National Human Rights Commission, courts and other relevant institutions.

Importantly, police officers must also be protected through clear rules governing lawful orders, professional conduct and the use of force.

Read also: Tinubu receives State Police Sixth Alteration Bill

A credible policing system requires officers to understand the limits of their authority and citizens to know where to seek redress when those limits are breached.

Beyond the constitutional and institutional questions, funding remains a major determinant of whether state police services can function effectively.

The financial capacity of Nigeria’s 36 states differs considerably. While some have relatively stronger internally generated revenue and infrastructure, others depend heavily on federal allocations to meet their recurrent obligations.

Requiring every state to establish and maintain a police service without addressing these disparities could create different standards of security across the federation.

A state with adequate revenue may be able to provide modern equipment, competitive remuneration, functional communication systems, training facilities and forensic infrastructure, while a financially weaker state may struggle to sustain basic policing operations.

This raises concerns about whether citizens’ access to effective security should depend on the revenue profile of the states in which they reside.

The National Policing Bill should therefore clarify the funding responsibilities of the Federal Government and state governments, including the structure of grants, eligibility requirements, disbursement procedures and financial accountability.

It should also consider shared national infrastructure for expensive services such as forensic laboratories, DNA and biometric databases, cybercrime investigation and specialised training.

The legislation must ensure that federal grants do not become instruments for controlling routine state police operations, while providing sufficient safeguards to ensure that public funds are properly utilised.

Read also: Senate transmits State Police bill to Tinubu for assent

Another critical consideration is whether all states should be allowed to establish police services immediately after the constitutional amendment receives presidential assent and the implementing legislation is passed.

The proposed framework envisages a phased arrangement under which states must enact their own enabling laws and demonstrate compliance with national minimum policing standards before commencing operations.

This requirement is important because the establishment of a police service involves more than recruiting officers and providing uniforms and vehicles.

States must demonstrate credible arrangements for recruitment, background checks, training, salaries, pensions, welfare, equipment, custody facilities, complaints handling, discipline, firearms control and financial sustainability.

Gbajabiamila had emphasised this requirement when the Presidential Working Group began consultations on the proposed legislation.

“A proposed State Police Service must demonstrate that it has credible arrangements for recruitment, vetting, training, pay, pensions, equipment, custody, complaints, discipline, data, firearms control, independent oversight and financial sustainability before it begins policing,” he said.

The National Policing Bill should translate these requirements into measurable standards and establish an independent process for assessing compliance.

It must also explain who conducts the assessments, how frequently certification is renewed, what happens when a state fails to meet the requirements and whether certification can be suspended or withdrawn.

Importantly, the standards should serve as minimum guarantees rather than prevent states from developing additional capabilities suited to their security needs.

Read also: National Assembly sets Tuesday deadline for state police bill returns 

The introduction of state police also raises questions about the future of existing subnational security organisations and community-based security formations.

Several states already operate security outfits, including Amotekun in the South-West, alongside vigilante groups and other locally established arrangements.

The National Policing Bill must clarify whether these organisations will be integrated into state police services, retained under separate legal frameworks or restructured.

It should provide for the screening and training of personnel who may be absorbed, the transfer or disposal of existing equipment and weapons, and safeguards against maintaining multiple armed institutions with overlapping responsibilities.

Without a clear transition plan, states could end up with parallel security structures whose command responsibilities and legal powers are difficult to distinguish.

The legislation must also address the regulation of private security companies and community-based vigilante organisations to prevent the proliferation of unauthorised armed groups.

For the National Assembly, the consideration of the National Policing Bill will require more than a speedy passage of another major security legislation.

Lawmakers must examine whether its provisions provide sufficient protection against political interference, establish workable federal-state coordination, guarantee independent oversight and create sustainable funding arrangements.

They must also scrutinise the 29 consequential amendment bills accompanying the proposed framework to ensure that existing laws governing policing, criminal justice, evidence, corrections and related institutions are consistent with the new arrangement.

Read also: All 36 states assemblies approve constitutional amendment for state police

The constitutional amendment may provide the foundation for decentralised policing, but the quality of its implementation will depend significantly on the details of the legislation.

As Nigeria prepares to move from a single national police structure to a dual system, the National Assembly faces the responsibility of ensuring that the reform strengthens security institutions without weakening citizens’ rights.

Ultimately, the success of state police should not be measured by the number of police commands established or officers recruited, but by whether Nigerians become safer, whether police institutions are accountable and whether citizens enjoy equal protection under the law irrespective of where they live.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *